Transitioning Your Loyalty Program From Points to Credit or Cashback

Sunsetting a points-based loyalty program and introducing a credit- or cashback-based model is a big moment for your brand — and a huge opportunity to reinvigorate customer engagement. The key to a successful transition is to make the shift clear, positive, and customer-focused while minimizing friction or confusion.

Here’s a best-practice approach broken into five phases:

‍

🔄 1. Strategic planning and internal alignment

‍

✅ Define:

• The cutover date from points to credits
• How points will be converted, expired, or retired
• What customer cohorts (VIPs, dormant users, etc.) need special handling
• How you’ll message the benefits of the new program (simplicity, transparency, value)

‍

💡 Best practice: To avoid customer pushback, assign a conversion rate (e.g., 100 points = $5) that feels fair or generous. Over-index on perceived value for top customers.

‍

📣 2. Communicate the change clearly and early

‍

✅ Give customers time:

• Announce the change at least 4–6 weeks before the sunset
• Use email, SMS, banners, and on-site messaging to educate
• Include a countdown and CTA: “Use your points before they expire!”

‍

🗣 Messaging tips:

• Frame it as an upgrade: “We’re making our rewards easier to use and more valuable.”
• Highlight new benefits: “You’ll now earn instant cashback instead of confusing points.”
• Show empathy: “We know change can be tricky, so we’re here to make this smooth.”

‍

💡 Best practice: Include FAQ links and support contact info in all announcements.

‍

🧮 3. Handle point conversions transparently

‍

You have three main options:

‍

Option A: Convert points to credit

• Convert unused points to store credit or cashback (e.g., 1,000 points = $10 credit)
• Ideal if you want to honor customer loyalty

‍

Option B: Encourage burn before cutoff

• Let customers redeem points under the old program until a specific date
• After that, points expire and customers join the new program

‍

Option C: Hybrid

• Give customers a window to use their points
• Then, automatically convert any leftovers to a gift card or credit balance

‍

💡 Best practice: Avoid making customers feel like they’re “losing” value. Even a symbolic conversion maintains trust.

‍

🧭 4. Launch the new program with excitement

‍

✅ Promote the benefits:

• Simple: “No more math — just money back.”
• Valuable: “Earn 5% on every order.”
• Flexible: “Use credits on anything, anytime.”

‍

💥 Ideas to drive momentum:

• Founding member bonuses for early adopters
• Double cashback for the first purchase under a new program
• “Meet the new perks” email series or walkthrough

‍

💡 Best practice: Let customers “see” their new balance right away, even if it’s small — it creates psychological buy-in.

‍

🧼 5. Post-launch cleanup and support

‍

✅ Ensure:

• Legacy data (point balances, transaction history) is archived and accessible
• Customer support is briefed and ready for FAQs
• Top customers are contacted 1:1 if needed

‍

📊 Track:

• Redemption rates (old vs. new)
• Enrollment and attach rate in the new program
• Feedback from customer support and surveys

‍

💡 Best practice: Use this moment to build stronger CX touchpoints. Send a follow-up: “Thanks for making the switch! Here’s a $5 reward just because you’re awesome.”

‍

✅ Summary checklist

‍

‍